Wealth Tax Supporters
Feedback
Report · Indonesia

PB 36 – Pajak Kekayaan: Peluang Integrasi Zakat dan Pajak Untuk Mengatasi Ketimpangan Sosial Ekonomi

A PRAKARSA policy brief arguing that a wealth tax and zakat do not conflict in Islamic law and can be run side by side, and comparing zakat collection in Indonesia with Malaysia.

Overview

Policy brief no. 36 of the Jakarta think tank The PRAKARSA, dated December 2022, asks whether combining zakat, the Islamic duty to give part of one's wealth, with a wealth tax can help close the gap between rich and poor in Indonesia. It is a companion to brief no. 35, which models the tax itself.

The brief starts from the numbers. Poverty reached 27.55 million people (10.19%) in September 2020, according to Statistics Indonesia (BPS). At the same time Credit Suisse counted 171,740 residents with a net worth of USD 1 million or more in 2020, up 61.69% from 106,215 in 2019. It defines a wealth tax as a rate applied to net worth, usually above a threshold, and reads Islamic history as giving it a basis: it says a caliph collected zakat on wealth to meet a drought and famine.

On the legal side it sets out two scholarly views, that tax and zakat are the same obligation or that they are different ones, and concludes that neither view rules out running both. It points to Malaysia, where zakat paid to an official body can offset tax by up to 100%, while Indonesia lets zakat paid to an approved body reduce taxable income (Law 36/2008 and Law 23/2011). It reports that BAZNAS puts Indonesia's zakat potential at IDR 327.6 trillion in 2020, of which about IDR 71.4 trillion (21.7%) was collected, and only IDR 10.2 trillion through the official agency. The average payment in 2019 was IDR 1.16 million a year per registered payer in Indonesia and IDR 10.2 million in Malaysia.

The brief recommends more transparent collection and distribution of zakat, digital collection that also serves as proof for tax deduction, and a mechanism that joins tax and zakat and brings in the non-government zakat bodies. It gives no wealth-tax rate, threshold or revenue estimate of its own.

Written from the records and links on this page.

On the record 1

Statements, votes and sponsorships in the register whose source is this report or one of its documents: 1 report.

People in the register 1

Authors and others who are on a register, each with the statement they rest on.